O’Brien faced 24 charges, including serious offenses like murder, arson, and unlawful use of a motor vehicle, all allegedly committed while on parole or under suspended sentences. Her bail application was complicated by multiple past breaches of bail conditions, a history of drug addiction, and mental health struggles. Despite the severity of the charges, particularly the alleged murder, the defense argued the evidence supporting a murder conviction was not strong. Justice Muir acknowledged the significant risks associated with granting bail, such as flight risk and potential reoffending, primarily linked to O’Brien’s history of drug use. Ultimately, the court decided that strict bail conditions—such as house arrest with her supportive mother, regular reporting to police, a curfew, and a significant financial surety—could sufficiently mitigate these risks, allowing for O’Brien’s release.
top of page
bottom of page