In Sharp v Commissioner of Police [2024] QDC 59, the District Court of Queensland addressed an appeal against conviction wherein Jody Anthony Sharp, the appellant, was initially found guilty of public nuisance at the Caloundra RSL. Challenging his conviction on the grounds that the failure of the prosecution to call two key witnesses constituted a miscarriage of justice, the appeal spotlighted procedural fairness and the obligations of the prosecution to ensure a fair trial. The appellate court, emphasising the prosecutor’s duty to call all material witnesses, found merit in Sharp's appeal, leading to the decision that the appellant was denied a fair trial. Consequently, the earlier conviction was set aside, a retrial was ordered, and the respondent, represented by the Commissioner of Police, was directed to bear the costs of the appeal amounting to $4,917.02.
top of page
bottom of page